A network that provides raw wiring from one location to another and introduces either very little or no processing to support the types of services that are running.
George Guilder, editor of "Guilder Technology Report," called the Internet "dumb"; well-known telecom consultant David Isenberg called it "stupid." They did that to contrast the Internet with the traditional telephone network, which has been called an "intelligent network" for years.
The Internet's thousands of routers are indeed intelligent devices, but they do rote forwarding. In contrast, telephone network switches are very aware of the services being carried and help to process them.
Dumb Means at the Edge
In order to add any new type of service to the "intelligent" telephone network, switches must be reprogrammed throughout the network. In contrast, the Internet serves as an oblivious transport, taking packets in and pushing them out the other side. New services and features are added at the periphery of the network by installing new software in users' PCs and in the servers, instead of revamping the internal network.
Perhaps It's Too Dumb
The Internet was never designed for quality of service (QoS), which can prioritize traffic and give real-time voice and video preference over data. In order to have voice over the Internet (VoIP) that is clear enough to "hear a pin drop" and have ubiquitous videoconferencing no matter which carrier's backbone is traversed, all the routers and switches in the Internet have to be upgraded to a common QoS standard. This is a work in progress (see infranet). See IP on Everything and IP telephony.
George Guilder, editor of "Guilder Technology Report," called the Internet "dumb"; well-known telecom consultant David Isenberg called it "stupid." They did that to contrast the Internet with the traditional telephone network, which has been called an "intelligent network" for years.
The Internet's thousands of routers are indeed intelligent devices, but they do rote forwarding. In contrast, telephone network switches are very aware of the services being carried and help to process them.
Dumb Means at the Edge
In order to add any new type of service to the "intelligent" telephone network, switches must be reprogrammed throughout the network. In contrast, the Internet serves as an oblivious transport, taking packets in and pushing them out the other side. New services and features are added at the periphery of the network by installing new software in users' PCs and in the servers, instead of revamping the internal network.
Perhaps It's Too Dumb
The Internet was never designed for quality of service (QoS), which can prioritize traffic and give real-time voice and video preference over data. In order to have voice over the Internet (VoIP) that is clear enough to "hear a pin drop" and have ubiquitous videoconferencing no matter which carrier's backbone is traversed, all the routers and switches in the Internet have to be upgraded to a common QoS standard. This is a work in progress (see infranet). See IP on Everything and IP telephony.
 | Reproduced with permission from Computer Desktop Encyclopedia. Copyright (c) 1981-2009 The Computer Language Company Inc. All rights reserved. |
Additional Resources
- Google's Chrome OS: Will you give up desktop apps?
- I won't ntntI can'tI'm not online 24/7. I need local apps, as does everyone else. Say what you want. But network outages happen... Weather by forces of nature or human error, a network will eventually go down. It's only a matter of time. And knowing Google's past GMail outages, I...
- Discussion threads 2009-11-19
- Memo to AT&T: When you're in a hole, stop digging
- AT&T and Apple were made for each otherBoth are whiny multi-national, multi-billion $$$/year mega corporations that sell substandard products and services to customers who don't know any better. Waaaaaaaaaa!!!!You said it exactly rightquote- [b]"You see, the company thinks consumers are too dumb to know the difference between 3G and non-3G...
- Discussion threads 2009-11-13
- Friday Challenge: What's your take on OS/browser market share trends?
- Firefox is taking over...With Firefox the days of vendor lock-in withIE required are over, like banking sites theyare cross-platform as they should be.I use CentOS/Fedora/RHEL and use I am able todo all of my job functions and use any applicationI want without the fear of security holes andthreats from a...
- Discussion threads 2009-11-13
- AT&T sues Verizon Wireless, calls map ad "misleading" but doesn't dispute accuracy
- The commercial it selfand the AT & T action on it, tell me to never EVER do any business with such a lousy and inferior company. AT&T? who, in is right mind will do business with those crooks?AT&T Focuses on Wrong Thing -- Again...Rather than trying to change its competitor's...
- Discussion threads 2009-11-03
- Client virtualization will help you create your next generation desktop
- Full circle to dumb terminal or network appliance right?RE: Client virtualization will help you create your next generation desktopAs always, speed is the unquantfied variable. If its good, then the apps will run great with no significant degradation. If not (as is usually the case with cost cutting companies now...
- Discussion threads 2009-11-02
- Google, Android 2.0 sticks fork in GPS devices
- It would also be great if Android could automatically re-route you in real-time, when things like the Bay Bridge suddenly close. This means munincipalities automatically posting closures on a web site, that all providers can use in real-time. Munincipalities could also distribute traffic in real-time. Lots of possibilities to replacing...
- Discussion threads 2009-10-28
- Typo takes down Internet in Sweden
- HeadlineI would have headlined this story "Sweden is Missing Its Period".RE: Typo takes down Internet in SwedenWhat does this imply for the rush to the cloud?RE: Typo takes down Internet in SwedenNot really the right headline.Really should read Typo blocks access to Swedish web-sites and email addresses, since they were...
- Discussion threads 2009-10-14
- The case of the fake money-mules: Inside the URLZone Trojan network
- Security EvangelistHi, boy I sure wish people would stop using the word Evangelist in the wrong way. An Evangelist is someone you preaches the Gospel of Jesus Christ, not a secular title at all. Wikipedia recently removed the secular definition and Webster is researching it. Evangelist is from the Greek...
- Discussion threads 2009-10-06
- Google exec calls for ISPs to get tough on botnets
- I can't agree with a requirement for active A/V.I don't need nor want useless A/V software on my systems.Its inappropriate for an ISP to scan MY machine..for paid access to the interent (when they want to claim they are a "dumb pipe"). If I am spewing out malware - sure,...
- Discussion threads 2009-09-23
- Doctor Antivirus 2008 (The ultimate guide to scareware protection)
- ScamsI have seen many of these screens before, on my own PC. I usually retreat to AVG, Norton, or Symantec sites to check their claims, do online scans, and Google search to find unhappy "users"RE: Doctor Antivirus 2008 The ultimate guide to scareware protectionthere ought to be laws... even so...
- Discussion threads 2009-09-14
- Cliq builds on iPhone idea, pushes away from smart"phone" category
- How about 'commer'?(A shortened version of communicator.) Moto gets points for coming up with the idea of making a specific function social easier with the Cliq. But putting all their eggs in the "social" basket seems risky. Isn't the appeal for this kind of limited in the overall market? We'll...
- Discussion threads 2009-09-11
- 10 things I think I think about Palm's Pixi webOS smartphone
- It looks like my Treo ProVery few differences from the front point of view.I don't get it. Is it a common knowledge thatSprint is a mediocre wireless carrier? Didn't you all complained that AT&T service sucks? if that is the case, what is left among major suppliers? Verizon? Some of...
- Discussion threads 2009-09-09
- If a flash drive infects a network, who's to blame?
- I think the answer could be both are to blame...More more data i could give a clear cut answer such as 1. was there a policy in place that addressed flash drive useage. 2. Did IT limit flash drive useage with admin tools. So who's to blame i cannot say...
- Discussion threads 2009-09-04
- Red Hat: Microsoft taking cloud back to the 80s
- Red Hat should feel right at home then because using their software is like using something out of the 80's. I'll prefer a modern company like Microsoft instead of a company based on 30 year old technology such as Red Hat. My theory is that Red Hat is...
- Discussion threads 2009-09-03
- Logitech debuts Squeezebox Radio, Touch network music players
- why does it have a touch screen again?the thing sit on top of you stereo so i have to get up off of the sofa ans walk across the room to interact with the touch screen.. that is so stupid!!the duet model had it right put the screen in the...
- Discussion threads 2009-09-03
- Is the Palm Pre a failure?
- Wrong, so what's right?You say the ads don't work.What kind of ads do you suggest would? I'm interested to hear what you think would be effective.Those silly adsI think the Palm Pre ads are worse than the initial Windows ads. They are really bad. Their only really good quality is...
- Discussion threads 2009-09-03
- AT&T actually offers iPhone customers the service they pay for?
- JudgingBy my decline in service in the DC Metro area over the last month, I'm hoping they moved our towers up to NYC.AT&T always does continual imporvementsSame as Verizon, Same as T-Mobile, Same as Sprint, etc...RE: AT&T actually offers iPhone customers the service they pay for?The next move for Apple...
- Discussion threads 2009-09-02
- RIM BlackBerry Storm 2 caught in the wild [video]
- The question is...What is the performance difference between the Storm 2 and the Storm? In its current form and firmware, the Storm is an excellent device. It is responsive and offers a rich user experience in terms of e-mail, web, tethering, and applications.My guess is that Rim decided...
- Discussion threads 2009-08-17
- Edubuntu followup
- A number of readers posed both thoughts and questions related to my Wednesday post, "The state of Edubuntu...Thoughts?" While the expected "Why the hell would you use *nix anyway?" sorts of questions were thrown in for good measure, many readers had solid recommendations based on experience while others had...
- Blog posts 2009-08-06
- File sharing leaks government secrets
- File sharing leaks government secretsSecuring a network...is a very simple task. However, it does require that the administrators actually be qualified and knowledgeable about their profession. During my 20 years in the technology profession it has become quite obvious that maybe 2 out of 10 professionals are actually qualified to...
- Discussion threads 2009-07-29
Neighboring Terms
Premier Vendor Content Whitepapers, webcasts & resources from our Power Center Sponsors
- The best support in the Linux business
-
If Linux is going to power your mission-critical applications, you'd better have the best support known to business. Novell was rated the top provider of Linux technical support.
- Learn more >>
- The best support in the Linux business
-
If Linux is going to power your mission-critical applications, you'd better have the best support known to business. Novell was rated the top provider of Linux technical support.
- Learn more >>
- Reduce risk. Reduce complexity. Increase reliability.
-
A simplified IT environment isn't just less complex. It's also more reliable. Standardize on a single Linux platform with SUSE Linux Enterprise from Novell, and get the world's most interoperable Linux
- Learn more >>
- The more you simplify, the more you save
-
When you transition from your existing Red Hat environment to SUSE Linux Enterprise from Novell, you can recognize dramatic cost savings, perhaps as much 50%
- Learn more >>
SmartPlanet
- Thought-provoking progressive ideas on diverse topics that intersect with technology, business, and life, and matter to the world at large. Visit SmartPlanet
- More from IBM
-
- Innovate your business' process model, play against the market, compete against others on our scoreboards and WIN! Try INNOV8 2.0: A BPM Simulator
- Enabling Real-World Business Transformation through IBM Service Management Read the EMA Analyst Report
